Every franchise process I have ever been involved in or overseen usually begins with a candidate asking this question within the first one or two phone calls, before I have really got to know who they are as an operator or a person. The question is: “How much money can I make?” Untrained sales teams will flounder and retort, “How much do you want to make?” or ask some other silly question that may allude to us, the franchise salesperson or executive, having a magic 8 ball that predicts an operator’s success. A more skilled salesperson will gather details before responding: What do they need each month to pay their bills? What cash flow do they have? What businesses have they run previously? What other roles have they held where they were responsible for successful outcomes, and how did they fare?
Now that is a question everyone should be asking their candidates.
The success equation relies on two parties: the franchisor and the franchisee. As much as a candidate looks to the franchisor for predictability of outcomes, so should the franchisor in its process to select the right fit for its brand.
Unfortunately, I’ve seen leads approach the process with the same focus: mapping out average unit volume and top-performer earnings, then preparing a chart trending confidently up and to the right based on top-line figures and top-performing franchisees. The better questions to ask are: How long have they been in the system? What experience did they have, and how quickly did they get there? Revenue tells you what came in the door. It tells you nothing about what it cost to get there, whether the people already running the business are happy, or whether the brand is built to last.
Here are the five numbers we advise candidates to chase down before they chase the top line.
1. Unit-level profitability
Not revenue — profit. A location doing $1.2 million a year sounds fantastic until the margins turn out to be razor-thin because labour, cost of goods or the royalty structure eats most of it. Ask for detail beyond gross sales. If the FDD doesn’t break out profitability, that absence is information too.
2. Franchisee turnover rate
Some turnover is normal — people retire, sell or move on. A lot of turnover, especially franchisor-initiated terminations, is a flashing warning light. Ask directly what’s driving it.
3. Validation response rate
This one won’t appear in any document — you build it yourself. Of the franchisees you call, how many call back, and how many answer honestly instead of reciting talking points? A system where franchisees are eager to talk, unprompted, is telling you something good. Unreturned calls and rehearsed answers tell you something else.
4. Support investment per franchisee
Look at how many field support staff exist relative to open units. A franchisor with 200 locations and four support coaches is stretched thin, no matter how good its intentions. Ask how support is structured, how often you’ll actually see someone in person, and what the escalation path looks like when something breaks.
5. Net unit growth, not gross openings
Growth headlines are easy to spin. A franchisor can open twenty units and close fifteen and still put out a press release about record expansion. Ask for net unit change over the past three years, not just openings. If the number is flat or shrinking while the sales pitch keeps talking growth, that gap is your answer.
Bottom line
None of these five numbers are hard to ask for. What’s hard is remembering to ask when you’re sitting across from someone good at their job who genuinely believes in what they’re selling. Belief isn’t due diligence, and a great pitch isn’t the same as a healthy system. Get the numbers first. Decide second.
Key takeaways
- Assess unit-level profit, not gross revenue, and ask for detail beyond sales.
- Treat high franchisee turnover, especially franchisor-initiated terminations, as a warning sign and ask what is driving it.
- Use franchisee validation calls to assess response rates and whether franchisees speak candidly.
- Compare field support staff with open units, and clarify how support and escalations work.
- Check net unit change over three years; gross openings can hide closures.





